Quarrel Forum

static_fury · #1 (**permalink**) 12 Nov 2005, 01:42

Do you think that the Homunculus did actualy have souls? Look at turners daughter she was just a doll, the body has no will without the soul. Personaly i think that they did have sould but the emblem on their bodies were there to control them and thus their real memories were block. And if you dont think they have souls, how do they possibly remeber? And they said through the whole series they didnt have souls, but at the ending eps we find out most everything wasnt true....What do you think?

naruto092005 · #2 (**permalink**) 13 Nov 2005, 03:05

greed and gluttony are da best

sakurablossom · #3 (**permalink**) 14 Nov 2005, 04:50

I think they do not have soul mainly memories of their former selves. They build up a hatred toward their creators or a passion of love.

Inyachan · #4 (**permalink**) 14 Nov 2005, 05:04

They could have souls in them or else they would be a living doll that could not think on its own.

listersgirl · #5 (**permalink**) 14 Nov 2005, 11:59

The whole series is about what it means to be human. I think that the homunculus don't have souls because they are in essence made by humans. The matter is simply transformed - only God can add that vital part. That is why human transmutation ultimately fails.

Anaconda · #6 (**permalink**) 14 Nov 2005, 12:06

Humunculous are born when an alchemist tries to recreate life. They are born with their own will, and their own mind, but no soul. That's the extent of my understanding of the series right now. However as is understood, they are not human

(Adding on to some material covered by the previous poster)

setesh · #7 (**permalink**) 15 Nov 2005, 22:52

They probably had their own souls that came frome the gate, those little weird black things that enjoy ripping body parts off of ppl.

Kiriga · #8 (**permalink**) 15 Nov 2005, 23:03

I think that they have something like souls. Not exactly something that can be named "soul"... but something. Or else it would be kinda empty in there

it would be too mean

Anyone that can explain what a soul is?

Then we'll probably know, kinda, if they have souls or what...

Niivalue · #9 (**permalink**) 17 Nov 2005, 10:33

Well if every other part of them came from the gate, maybe their souls did too?

listersgirl · #10 (**permalink**) 18 Nov 2005, 00:07

But if they had souls wouldn't they just be regular humans? Then why wouldn't human transmutation work?